One Player, One Position, One Defining Season

Kevin looks at dynasty assets who must have a good season this year.

Dynasty value does not stay patient forever. Every offseason, there are players we keep making excuses for. The talent is still there. The situation could improve. The breakout is coming. The price will bounce back. Sometimes that patience pays off, but other times we hold too long and watch an asset slowly lose insulation.

For this article, we are going position by position and looking at one player at each spot who is entering a defining dynasty season. These are not automatic sells. They are not all bad players. Some are still young. Some have flashed. Some still have a clear path to becoming useful dynasty pieces. The problem is that their value windows are starting to tighten.

At quarterback, running back, wide receiver, and tight end, there are players who need 2026 to answer a real question. If they hit, the market could come back quickly. If they disappoint again, dynasty managers may not get another clean exit window. The clock is ticking.

Bryce Young, QB, Carolina Panthers

TDR Ranking: QB24
KTC Ranking: QB23

Picking one quarterback was tough for this exercise. There are plenty of names that could qualify here. Cam Ward, Tyler Shough, Kyler Murray, Tua Tagovailoa, and Michael Penix Jr. all have some level of pressure attached to this season.

For me, though, the pick is Bryce Young. The Panthers picked up Young’s fifth-year option, so this is not a situation where Carolina is completely out on him. He is still under contract through 2027. But that does not mean his dynasty value is safe. This still feels like a crossroads season for the former No. 1 overall pick.

Young has taken small steps forward during his time as the starter, but the problem is that the steps have not been big enough. Last season, he set career highs in passing yards, touchdown passes, and completion percentage. He also posted the lowest sack rate of his career. That all sounds good on the surface.

The issue is the overall production still has not been enough. Young averaged just 188.2 passing yards per game and 6.3 yards per attempt last season. There were also games where it felt like Dave Canales was trying to protect him and keep the offense from putting too much on his plate. Young attempted 25 or fewer passes in half of his starts, which tells you a lot about where this offense was.

That has carried over to fantasy. Young has finished as the QB29, QB24, and QB25 in fantasy points per game across his first three seasons. There have been flashes, and there are moments where you still see why he went first overall. He can create outside of structure, he can move around, and when things break down, he still has some of that playmaking ability that made him such a good prospect.

But we are doing a lot of heavy lifting to paint the optimistic picture. At some point, the production has to match the excuses. Young is still young. He turns 25 in July. Carolina has not exactly given him elite supporting casts during his career. The offensive environment has been inconsistent. All of that matters.

The problem is that the numbers we care about still do not paint a great picture. His passing success rate, yards per attempt, yards per game, touchdown rate, passer rating, and sack rate all sit near the bottom when compared to quarterbacks with similar early-career starting experience since 2000. That is hard to ignore.

This is why 2026 matters so much. Carolina’s offense should be better around him. Tetairoa McMillan already looks like a legitimate No. 1 wide receiver after a strong rookie season. Jalen Coker showed some flashes when healthy. Chris Brazzell gives them another vertical element. The wide receiver room is not elite, but it is better than what Young has had in previous seasons.

There are still concerns, though. The tight end room does not really move the needle, and the offensive line has some real questions. Ikem Ekwonu’s injury is a big deal, and the Panthers are going to have to figure out the left tackle spot. For a quarterback who has already had issues with pressure and consistency, that matters. The offensive structure is also a concern for fantasy. Canales and Brad Idzik are back, but the results have not been good enough. Carolina has been near the bottom of the league in total offense and scoring the last two seasons, and last year they leaned more run-heavy. Unless Young forces this offense to open up, I do not know if the volume is going to be there for a real fantasy ceiling.

That leaves Young in a weird spot. There is still a path to a solid QB2 season. The weapons are better. He can give you some modest rushing production. If the efficiency finally takes a jump, he could stabilize his value and remind people why he was once viewed as a cornerstone dynasty asset.

But the downside is pretty clear too. We have already seen Young get benched once in his career. If he struggles again this season, I do not know how patient Carolina will be. The fifth-year option gives him time on paper, but another middling season would make it hard for dynasty managers to keep treating him like a long-term starter.

That is why the clock is ticking. Young does not have to become an elite fantasy quarterback overnight, but he does need to show he is more than a low-end QB2 who needs everything around him to be perfect. If he takes a real step, there is still value to be gained. If he gives us another season of modest production, limited ceiling, and shaky efficiency, the market may finally stop waiting.

Dynasty League Trades 12 Team/SF TE Premium

• Bryce Young FOR Ted Hurst/Matthew Stafford

• Bryce Young FOR 2027 1st

• Bryce Young FOR Parker Washington/2027 2nd

• Bryce Young FOR DJ Moore

• Bryce Young FOR 2027 2nd

Dear Readers,

If you’re looking to get a real head start in your dynasty, devy, or C2C leagues, consider joining either our Substack or the website. Both provide actionable, edge-driven content built to help you stay ahead of the field.

Substack is our most affordable option at just $7/month and gives you access to all of our written content.

For those who want everything in one place, the website offers three membership tiers ($8/$12/$16) and includes all written content plus exclusive tools, rankings, features, and community access.

However you choose to support us, we truly appreciate you being part of what we’re building and trusting us to help you win.